WARNING: This article includes information about violence against children and attempted suicide.
The testimony phase wrapped up on Wednesday in the murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, a mother charged with the strangulation of her three young children, a case that has highlighted issues surrounding postpartum mental health.
Closing arguments are anticipated to commence on Thursday, paving the way for the jury to begin their deliberations.
Clancy, 36, has entered a plea of not guilty by reason of diminished criminal responsibility, with her defense team asserting that she was suffering from postpartum psychosis at the time she killed her five-year-old daughter Cora, three-year-old son Dawson, and eight-month-old son Callan Clancy in their home located in coastal Duxbury, Massachusetts, in January 2023.
This uncommon mental health condition is associated with the pressures, lack of sleep, and hormonal fluctuations that can occur following childbirth.
FBI forensic psychiatrist provides testimony
The prosecution contends that Clancy premeditated the murders and was aware that her actions were wrong.
Clancy did not take the stand during the trial, which has now entered its fifth week. The defense called ten witnesses, including friends and family members, while the prosecution presented over 70 witnesses, among them her then-husband.
In his role as the final rebuttal witness for the prosecution, a forensic psychiatrist from the University of Virginia and a senior psychiatrist in the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit expressed skepticism regarding Clancy’s claim that she was directed by a voice to kill her children.
Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague posed a series of questions to Dr. Gregory Saathoff regarding Clancy’s assertions: Did the voice instruct her on how to kill the children? Where to do it? What tools to use? In what sequence? Saathoff replied negatively to each inquiry.
“The fact that she executed these decisions without any guidance is quite surprising,” he stated.

Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Gregory Saathoff was one of the last witnesses to testify in the trial. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger/The Associated Press)
All three children were killed by strangulation with exercise bands in the basement of their home before Clancy attempted suicide while her husband was out picking up takeout and at a pharmacy on January 24, 2023. Saathoff remarked that her ability to carry out these actions without any direction suggested that Clancy “had control over the sequence of her actions.”
“The brief window of time that Miss Clancy had alone in the house with her children was crucial for executing this plan, as well as her suicide, and it required her to act swiftly and methodically,” he explained.
On Tuesday, Saathoff noted it was peculiar that Clancy claimed the voice ceased once she had finished strangling the children, that the voice was continuous rather than sporadic, and that she had never previously reported hearing a voice to her healthcare providers. Additionally, he indicated that she provided inconsistent timelines to other evaluators regarding when she first heard the voice that day.
“The act itself does not seem to alleviate the voice,” Saathoff remarked about the abrupt cessation of the voice. “I have never encountered that before.”
Challenges to psychiatrist’s expertise in postpartum psychosis
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington commenced his cross-examination of Saathoff on Wednesday by seeking to question Saathoff’s qualifications regarding postpartum psychosis and depict him as closely tied to law enforcement, probing into his affiliations with prisons, the Justice Department, and the Virginia attorney general’s office.
Saathoff affirmed that he had treated women suffering from postpartum psychosis during his tenure at a state hospital in the 1980s and 1990s, although much of his recent research has concentrated on topics such as extremist violence, national security, and political radicalization.
Reddington also questioned Saathoff about Clancy’s online searches for information on postpartum depression, her visits to several maternal and mental health specialists, her disclosures to her mother and then-husband regarding suicidal thoughts and fears of harming her children, and her calls to a suicide hotline—arguments Reddington suggested demonstrated Clancy’s awareness that something was significantly wrong and her genuine attempts to seek help over time.
Reddington inquired if Saathoff believed Clancy decided to murder her children due to dissatisfaction with the life she envisioned and was making “a selfish choice” to “manipulate her providers, seeking a quick fix in her depressed and anxious state.”
“I think that statement minimizes what she was experiencing,” Saathoff replied.
If you or someone you know is in need of support, here are some resources:
- Canada’sSuicide Crisis Helpline: Call or text 988.
- Provincial and territorialmental health support.
- Kids Help Phone: 1-800-668-6868. Text 686868. Live chat counselling onthe website.
- This guide from theCentre for Addiction and Mental Healthoutlines how to discuss suicide with someone you are concerned about.

